Friday, December 16, 2011

Deja Vu Blogfest -- A Taste of Magic

So in reading one of my favorite bloggers early this morning, (thanks Laura!), I discovered that today is Deja Vu Blogfest. What fun!

In looking back over my earlier posts from over a year ago, I decided to revisit this one, because, to be honest, it needed a touch-up.

Hope you enjoy a second, improved helping of A Taste of Magic. Oh, and please skip over to Wednesday's guest post from fabulous debut author Michael L. Martin, Jr. and post a comment on A Sense of Wonder to win a copy of his book Burn in Hades. Winner will be announced in this space at noon today EST. So hurry!

Congratulations Suzanne Lucero!  You're the winner of Michael's book Burn in Hades!  I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.  I'll send you an e-mail about which format.


A Taste of Magic

When working with an element unfamiliar to your reader, such as a certain magical spell or fantastical beast, it is important to introduce how your creation works before using it in an important situation, especially a situation that involves a twist or mystery.  You have to play fair with your reader by exposing the magical function before the magical result is critical to the story.

J.K. Rowling was really good about this.  For example, we saw McGonagall transform as an animagus long before the Padfoot, Wormtail, Prongs, and Mooney thread of Prisoner of Azkaban.  Likewise, Jo introduced the Polyjuice potion as a relatively minor plot point in Chamber of Secrets before it became a major potion of concealment two books later.

In looking at Goblet of Fire, I found two magical elements that JKR deliberately introduced to her reader at the beginning of the story which played a crucial role in its climax: the Portkey and Prior Incantato.  Early in the book, Mr. Diggory used Prior Incantato to discover the last spell cast from the wand Winky had been discovered with...Harry's own.  Hermione gasped in horror as a shadow of the Dark Mark emerged from Harry's lost wand.

When traveling to the Quidditch World Cup, Mr. Weasley tells Harry that the Portkey they are about to take is an object "used to transport wizards from one spot to another at a prearranged time.  You can do large groups at a time if you need to."  And when Harry asks what type of objects they are, he replies, "Well, they can be anything...Unobtrusive things, obviously, so Muggles don't go picking them up and playing with them." (p. 70, GoF).

Portkeys can be anything...like a TriWizard Tournament Cup! And mirroring the beginning of the book, Cedric takes hold of the Portkey along with Harry to a meeting that involves Death Eaters.  At the dark moment, however, the Portkey transports Harry and Cedric into a much more deadly encounter where Cedric loses his life and Prior Incantato unleashes "the ghost of a spell" (p. 136) that reveals Harry's deceased mother and father.

When working with new elements, magical or otherwise, that play a crucial role in the climax or mystery of your story, it's important to be sure that you have introduced your reader to them, and the way they work, beforehand.  Give your reader a taste of magic early on by introducing creations of your own imagination in such a way that your reader can be an active participant in discovering your story's secrets.  Don't just spring a crucial surprise on them that they could not have guessed.  They'll feel cheated.

What magical or fantastical elements have you introduced into your story and how have you introduced your reader to its important function?

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
One of my favorite things about the Harry Potter books is how well JK foreshadows and hints at what's to come. I've re-read them so many times I'm pretty sure I've caught everything, but it was so so much fun re-reading them all the first and second time.
1 reply · active 693 weeks ago
I'm STILL catching things I didn't the first *cough hundred cough* times through. :-) Thanks Laura!.
I love how she foreshadows too but the portkey is inconsistently used - at the beginning of the story, the portkey has a predetermined time when it 'activates'. Later, Harry and Cedric only have to touch it, and later on again, harry uses it to return when that has not been set up - Mr Weasley or someone tossed it into a bin with other used portkeys when they arrived for the QWC, implying that portkeys usage is one-off. This inconsistency jarred for me so is not a perfect example for highlighting techniques.
2 replies · active 693 weeks ago
Hi Char, you point out some crucial considerations in the use of magical elements, which really requires a post of its own -- the inconsistencies and the side effects. To be honest, while I also noted the things you mentioned when I read GoF, I kind of assumed that there were various types of Portkeys that performed differently depending on their "programming." The thing is, JKR never spells this out completely, which is quite common with her. It's hard to close in all the loop holes of every magical element you produce when these details can slow down the forward pace of your novel.

However, the aspect that's really more jarring, in my POV, is when you introduce a magical element that when compared with or thrust into other parts of the story, can create loopholes. The portkey is also a good example here -- If portkeys can get people into and out of Hogwarts, why wasn't it used many times before? Again, it could be explained that portkeys have to be authorized and Crouch went to a lot of trouble to get this one working, but it's still slightly unstable. That's why magical elements are always a bit risky and need to be really well thought out.

In the end, the main aspect of the portkey and how it would function in the story was introduced early, even if other aspects of this element may be troublesome.

On another topic, are you the wonderful person who left a fabulous review for Writer's Guide to Harry Potter on Amazon? If so, thank you, thank you, thank you!!!! :-)
You're welcome :-) I bought the book about a month or so ago and while reading I scribbled notes on how I could apply this technique then that one to my own WIP. When I found myself going back to a page I had bookmarked I realised I have gained more skills from reading your book than I have from a few popular books on writing, so did my bit to let the world know. I agree with your underlying principle to learn from the best!
Leslie Rose's avatar

Leslie Rose · 693 weeks ago

Agree, agree, agree that the "magic" or "power" has to take root before it become a pivot point in the story, otherwise it feels like a cheap trick.
My recent post Testing Insanity

Post a new comment

Comments by